Gatorlyte vs Gatorade Thirst Quencher: which has more electrolytes?

Gatorlyte powder has almost twice the sodium of Gatorade Thirst Quencher powder (420 mg against 230 mg per stick) and more than four times the potassium (300 mg against 70 mg), with 9 g of sugar against 32 g. Gatorlyte also lists magnesium, calcium and chloride, which Gatorade's label does not.

By James Fayal · Labels checked November 17, 2026 · Every number is read from the brand's own label · Zest Elite is shown in the last column

Zest makes Zest Elite. We are not affiliated with the other brands; their names are their owners' trademarks. Amazon links to other brands are affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate, Zest earns from qualifying purchases.

Per serving, from each label
Per servingGatorlyteGatorade Thirst QuencherZest Elite
Sodium420 mg230 mg1,100 mg
Potassium300 mg70 mg320 mg
Magnesium95 mg0 mg§40 mg
Calcium100 mg0 mg§60 mg
Chloride640 mg–2,000 mg
Total electrolytes1,555 mg300 mg†3,520 mg
Serving1 stick (15 g)1 stick (35 g)1 stick (11 g)
Sugar9 g32 g0 g §
Calories451300 §
CreatineNoneNone5 g
SweetenerSugar + purified stevia leaf extractSugar, dextroseStevia leaf extract

† Gatorade Thirst Quencher lists no chloride and it cannot be worked out, so its total covers the listed minerals only. § Gatorade Thirst Quencher: The label says it is not a significant source of calcium, so calcium is shown as 0. § Gatorade Thirst Quencher: The label has no magnesium line and no ingredient contains magnesium, so it is shown as 0. § Zest Elite: The Supplement Facts panel has no line for sugar or calories. FDA labeling rules require one unless the amount rounds to zero, so each is shown as 0.

Which has more electrolytes, Gatorlyte or Gatorade?

Gatorlyte. One stick lists 420 mg sodium, 300 mg potassium, 95 mg magnesium, 100 mg calcium and 640 mg chloride, 1,555 mg in all. One stick of Gatorade Thirst Quencher powder lists 230 mg sodium and 70 mg potassium, 300 mg in all. Both figures are for the powder sticks, from PepsiCo's product-facts panels.

Does Gatorlyte have less sugar than Gatorade?

Yes. Gatorlyte's panel lists 9 g of sugar and 45 calories per 15 g stick, from sugar, with stevia leaf extract. Gatorade Thirst Quencher powder lists 32 g of sugar and 130 calories per 35 g stick. Gatorade Zero powder has 0 g of sugar and lists 270 mg sodium and 80 mg potassium.

Is Gatorlyte made by Gatorade?

Yes. Both are Gatorade products from PepsiCo. Gatorlyte has more electrolytes and less sugar per stick; Thirst Quencher is the original formula.

Should you choose Gatorlyte or Gatorade Thirst Quencher?

Choose Gatorlyte if you want more electrolytes with less sugar. Choose Gatorade Thirst Quencher if you want the sugar as fuel during long exercise.

How does Zest Elite compare with both?

Zest Elite has more sodium than either (1,100 mg against 420 mg and 230 mg), 0 g of sugar, and adds 5 g of creatine monohydrate, which neither contains. Gatorlyte has more magnesium (95 mg against 40 mg) and calcium (100 mg against 60 mg) than Zest Elite. On chloride, Zest Elite has 2,000 mg to Gatorlyte's 640 mg, and Gatorade Thirst Quencher gives no figure.

Sources

More comparisons

#1 in sodium and chloride. 5 g creatine. One stick.

Zest Elite has 1,100 mg sodium and 2,000 mg chloride, the most of the 37 products in our comparison chart. Zero sugar, three flavors.

Shop Zest Elite