Teas
Liquid I.V. has more sodium (500 mg against 420 mg) and more potassium (370 mg against 300 mg) per stick. Gatorlyte lists five electrolytes, including 95 mg magnesium and 100 mg calcium, and has slightly less sugar (9 g against 11 g).
Zest makes Zest Elite. We are not affiliated with the other brands; their names are their owners' trademarks. Amazon links to other brands are affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate, Zest earns from qualifying purchases.
| Per serving | Gatorlyte | Liquid I.V. | Zest Elite |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sodium | 420 mg | 500 mg | 1,100 mg |
| Potassium | 300 mg | 370 mg | 320 mg |
| Magnesium | 95 mg | 0 mg§ | 40 mg |
| Calcium | 100 mg | 0 mg | 60 mg |
| Chloride | 640 mg | – | 2,000 mg |
| Total electrolytes | 1,555 mg | 870 mg†| 3,520 mg |
| Serving | 1 stick (15 g) | 1 stick (16 g) | 1 stick (11 g) |
| Sugar | 9 g | 11 g | 0 g § |
| Calories | 45 | 50 | 0 § |
| Creatine | None | None | 5 g |
| Sweetener | Sugar + purified stevia leaf extract | Cane sugar, dextrose, stevia leaf extract | Stevia leaf extract |
†Liquid I.V. lists no chloride and it cannot be worked out, so its total covers the listed minerals only. § Liquid I.V.: The label has no magnesium line and no ingredient contains magnesium, so it is shown as 0. § Zest Elite: The Supplement Facts panel has no line for sugar or calories. FDA labeling rules require one unless the amount rounds to zero, so each is shown as 0.
Gatorlyte on AmazonLiquid I.V. on AmazonZest Elite on Amazon
On sodium and potassium, Liquid I.V.: 870 mg against Gatorlyte's 720 mg. Counting everything on each label, Gatorlyte: 420 mg sodium, 300 mg potassium, 95 mg magnesium, 100 mg calcium and 640 mg chloride, 1,555 mg in all, plus 250 mg phosphorus that is left out of the totals here. Liquid I.V.'s label lists no magnesium or chloride.
The figures here are from PepsiCo's product-facts panel. Gatorade's own product-page FAQ gives higher ones, including 490 mg sodium and 350 mg potassium. We use the panel.
Liquid I.V. has 11 g of sugar and 50 calories per stick, from cane sugar and dextrose, with stevia. Gatorlyte's panel lists 9 g of sugar and 45 calories, from sugar, with stevia; a retail label photo of the stick shows 10 g.
Liquid I.V. adds vitamin C and four B vitamins. Gatorlyte lists no vitamins. Neither product page states third-party testing.
Choose Liquid I.V. for a little more sodium and potassium, vitamins and many more flavors. Choose Gatorlyte if you want magnesium and calcium in the mix or slightly less sugar.
Zest Elite has more sodium than both (1,100 mg), no sugar and 5 g of creatine monohydrate, which neither contains. Gatorlyte has more magnesium (95 mg against 40 mg) and calcium (100 mg against 60 mg); Liquid I.V. has more potassium (370 mg against 320 mg). Its chloride, 2,000 mg, is about three times Gatorlyte's 640 mg; Liquid I.V. does not print chloride.
Zest Elite has 1,100 mg sodium and 2,000 mg chloride, the most of the 37 products in our comparison chart. Zero sugar, three flavors.